Made for Authors
Convert Feedback Into a Revision Strategy
Also useful for: people in Creative, people in Writers
You sort editorial and early-reader notes into root problems, competing interpretations, and actionable decisions. Leave with a revision order, targeted tests, and concise replies for each feedback source.
Create a free account to save your progress and use this Playbook.
Use this when
Use this after you receive substantial notes from an editor, agent, critique partner, sensitivity reader, or early-reader group. It's especially useful when comments conflict, proposed fixes don't fit your intent, or the volume of feedback makes it hard to see what matters most.
You'll need
- Manuscript context
- Intended reader experience
- Feedback notes
- Feedback source context
- Creative non-negotiables
- Revision deadline
- Working relationship context
- Testing tolerance
You'll get
- Every meaningful note recorded once and linked to a source
- Symptoms separated from proposed fixes
- Related notes grouped under root problems
- Every material conflict resolved or framed
- Accept, Test, Decline, or Clarify assigned to each note
- A ranked plan that handles dependencies and defines success
By the end of this playbook
You will have:
- Every meaningful note recorded once and linked to a source
- Symptoms separated from proposed fixes
- Related notes grouped under root problems
- Every material conflict resolved or framed
- Accept, Test, Decline, or Clarify assigned to each note
- A ranked plan that handles dependencies and defines success
Sample
This is sample data, not your prompt. Pro unlocks this higher-stakes Playbook. On Free Playbooks you can still copy the assembled prompt into any AI.
Sample input
You are revising an 82,000-word adult mystery. Your editor says chapters 5 through 8 lose momentum and recommends cutting Mara's family scenes. One early reader wants more time with Mara before the second body is found. Another wants the second body found sooner. Your intended effect is growing dread while Mara's family obligations make escape harder. You want to preserve the family pressure but can shorten or reposition scenes. You have six weeks and owe your editor a revision plan by Friday.
Sample assembled prompt
Your strategic readout identifies a likely... You don't treat the opposing timing... Your decisions: - Accept: The middle... - Decline: Cut all family scenes,... - Test: Rewrite the chapter 6... - Test: Move the second body's... - Clarify: Ask your editor whether... Your first revision priority is to... Your second priority is to test... Your line edits wait until both...